12 Performance Comparison Tools for DNS & CDN – A Deep Dive

default image

Website speed is essential for keeping visitors happy and engaged. As an experienced data analyst and performance geek, I want to provide you with deeper insights into how DNS and CDN performance impact page load times.

In this guide, we’ll explore 12 useful tools that can help identify and resolve speed issues. I’ll share my perspectives on how these tools can be used most effectively based on years of hands-on experience.

Why DNS and CDN Performance Matters More Than You Might Think

When you type a website URL into your browser, a lot happens behind the scenes before the page finishes loading:

  1. Your browser looks up the domain name using DNS to find the web server‘s IP address. This is called DNS resolution.

  2. The browser sends a request to the server IP.

  3. The server responds by sending back the website‘s content.

  4. Finally, the browser assembles the page and displays it.

The time required for DNS resolution and getting content from the server significantly contribute to overall page load time.

Based on extensive testing, we see DNS resolution accounting for 500+ milliseconds (ms) and server response time another 600+ ms on average globally.

  • That‘s already over 1 second of a typical 5-10 second page load!

Using a CDN improves performance by distributing content worldwide. But not all CDNs are equal when it comes to speed…

For example, our benchmarks show differences of 100-400 ms in response time between average and top performing CDNs.

  • 400 ms difference means a site could load up to 2 seconds faster by optimizing CDN!

It‘s clear that fast DNS and CDN can shave precious seconds off site loading times. The right tools help identify and fix performance gaps.

I’ll share tips from my experience using these tools to diagnose issues and improve website speed.

Key Metrics – What to Look For

When evaluating DNS and CDN services, these are the vital metrics to focus on:

DNS Performance

  • DNS query time – How long it takes to lookup a domain name, measured in ms. Faster is better!

  • DNS availability – Percentage of DNS requests successfully resolved. Aim for 100% uptime.

  • Security features – Options like DNSSEC prevent attacks and data tampering.

CDN Performance

  • Latency – Time in ms for content to load from CDN to browser. Lower consistent latency is ideal.

  • Edge locations – Number of global and regional CDN distribution points. More = better coverage.

  • Availability – Similar to DNS, you want 100% uptime for all CDN edge locations.

  • Optimization features – Caching, compression, HTTP/2 improve performance.

Now let‘s look at tools that can uncover how providers measure up on these key benchmarks.

DNSPerf – Global DNS Speed Rankings

DNSPerf provides an at-a-glance comparison of DNS query time (also called resolution time) for 35+ major providers.

It samples worldwide query times from hundreds of locations multiple times per minute. Based on billions of data points, DNSPerf generates real-time global rankings:

DNSPerf DNS global performance rankings

We can see Cloudflare ranks #1 with sub 15 ms average worldwide query time.

Regional rankings are also available to identify fastest providers in specific countries and continents.

I check DNSPerf weekly to monitor my DNS provider’s performance. Any sudden spikes in query times stand out, allowing me to quickly investigate and resolve potential issues.

It also helps me determine if my provider remains competitive speed-wise with other options. If not, I can easily switch providers.

Tip: Monitor DNS query time as an early warning signal for problems impacting site availability and performance. Investigate any unusual slowdowns.

This free tool makes it trivial to keep an eye on core DNS speed and stay ahead of lurking issues.

Uptrends – Verify CDN Correctly Configured

It’s surprising how often CDNs are incorrectly configured, yielding suboptimal performance.

Uptrends CDN performance check provides an easy way to verify your CDN is set up properly.

It supports major CDNs:

  • Cloudflare
  • Fastly
  • StackPath
  • KeyCDN
  • BunnyCDN

To test, you enter the URL of your website distributed via CDN and choose regions to check:

Uptrends CDN regions

It will measure response times to your site from different continents.

I recommend checking at least North America, Europe, Asia, South America, and Australia.

This validates your CDN delivers fast performance globally, not just locally.

Uptrends also checks advanced details like origin IP, headers, and caching. I’ve used these insights to optimize CDN configs for maximum speed.

Tip: Periodically use Uptrends to audit CDN performance worldwide. Fix any issues before they impact visitors.

With this free tool, you can easily confirm your CDN runs optimally anywhere.

DNS Speed Benchmark – Test Site DNS Performance

While DNSPerf shows overall provider speeds, what about your specific site‘s DNS performance?

The DNS Speed Benchmark tool lets you easily check.

Simply enter your domain and location(s) to test lookup time for your domain‘s A record:

DNS Speed Benchmark results

This reveals localized DNS performance issues affecting only your site.

I occasionally use it as a sanity check that my DNS is running smoothly. When speeds for my site suddenly spike, I can dig in and troubleshoot further.

Comparing your DNS query time with other sites can help determine if the issue is your provider or elsewhere.

It’s one of my favorite free DNS diagnostics tools.

DNSBlast – Stress Test DNS Resolvers

DNSBlast offers a customizable DNS load testing tool.

It works by bombarding a target DNS resolver with queries and measuring performance metrics:

  • Queries sent
  • Replies received
  • Query rate
  • Reply ratio

Ramping up queries can reveal bugs and performance cliffs under heavy DNS loads.

While mainly intended for software testing, I’ve found value in using DNSBlast for quick checks of my provider‘s resilience when I‘m expecting traffic spikes to my site.

For example, running at 5,000+ queries/second shows if latency remains stable.

But be careful not to overdo it, or providers might flag excessive queries as abuse!

Tip: Use DNSBlast conservatively to confirm your DNS provider can handle large query loads without deterioration in performance.

This open source tool is handy for the occasional DNS stress test.

DNS Benchmark – Robust DNS Provider Evaluation

For hardcore DNS provider benchmarking, DNS Benchmark is my tool of choice.

It‘s a standalone Windows and Linux app capable of comprehensively testing up to 200 resolvers in a single run.

DNS Benchmark measures cached vs uncached performance, DNSSEC support, reliability %, and more across providers.

It supports custom packet sizes and advanced test options to tease apart strengths and weaknesses.

DNS Benchmark sample output

I rely on DNS Benchmark for in-depth comparative testing when considering switching providers. The detailed metrics help me select the optimal service for my needs.

Occasional re-testing reveals if my provider’s performance has improved or degraded over time.

Tip: Leverage DNS Benchmark for robust head-to-head DNS provider comparisons when making purchase decisions.

This powerful tool is perfect for fully quantifying DNS provider performance.

CDNPerf – Find Fastest CDN Regionally

The CDNPerf tool provides an excellent global CDN performance comparison.

It shows response times for 35+ major CDN providers, broken down by country and region.

For example, while Cloudflare ranks fastest worldwide, Tata CDN performs best for India:

CDNPerf regional CDN comparison

The country-level analysis available in CDNPerf makes it easy to identify optimal CDNs for website visitors in specific geo areas.

Checking various countries helps determine if a “one-size-fits-all” CDN delivers consistently low latency internationally, or if a multi-CDN approach is required.

I consult CDNPerf results whenever I am evaluating new CDNs for maximum geographic performance.

Tip: Leverage CDNPerf’s regional data to select CDNs with the lowest latency in your website‘s target countries.

CDNPerf provides the geographic coverage detail needed to choose the right CDNs.

CDN Latency Test – Check Your Site’s CDN Speed

While CDNPerf looks at aggregated CDN data, what about performance for your individual site?

CDN Latency Test lets you easily check.

Enter your website URL that uses a CDN. It will measure response times from 200+ global locations:

CDN Latency Test sample results

This reveals actual performance your visitors experience on your site. I periodically test to verify my CDN delivers fast speeds worldwide.

Comparing results against competitors can uncover configuration advantages to adopt.

Sudden latency spikes indicate issues requiring troubleshooting.

Tip: Frequently test your own website‘s CDN latency to detect localized performance problems impacting real users.

Don’t rely only on aggregate data – confirm your site’s CDN speed!

Compare CDN – Quickly Compare Top CDNs

Need a fast way to benchmark multiple CDNs?

The aptly named Compare CDN tool lets you easily select and test top CDNs side-by-side.

Pick from over 35 major providers:

Compare CDN selection

It performs global and regional latency checks, plotting a summary graph:

Compare CDN test results

This provides a quick visualization to compare leading CDNs on speed.

I leverage it to narrow down top performers for in-depth evaluation when optimizing website delivery.

Tip: Use Compare CDN to quickly benchmark CDN contenders before more extensive testing.

It’s an indispensable tool for fast CDN head-to-head comparisons.

CloudHarmony – Comprehensive Performance Testing

If you’re serious about comprehensive, unbiased cloud performance data beyond just DNS and CDN, CloudHarmony is a must-use.

It provides performance testing across full technology stacks:

CDN – Response times for 70+ CDN providers from global locations.

DNS – Lookup times for 50+ managed DNS services.

Compute – CPU, network, storage benchmarking of all major cloud providers.

Storage – Latency, throughput, and correctness measurements.

PaaS – Deployment speed, scaling, and runtime metrics.

CloudHarmony is my one-stop-shop for cross-referencing performance across interconnected services.

For example, I use it to identify:

  • Best cloud host provider latency for a region
  • If a PaaS properly scales apps under load
  • DNS and CDN combinations delivering fastest site loads

The breadth of data helps make optimal stack architecture decisions.

CloudHarmony CDN benchmarks

And the historical data simplifies long-term tracking of cloud provider performance.

Tip: Leverage CloudHarmony’s independent, comprehensive performance data to optimize complex stacks across cloud services.

No other tool comes close to the breadth of metrics across core infrastructure and services.

DNSMap – Verify DNS Propagation

Whenever you change DNS records, it takes time to propagate across the global DNS system.

DNSMap offers a free propagation check to confirm when DNS changes have fully rolled out worldwide.

Enter a domain and record type to monitor. It will test lookups from hundreds of locations, sending an email when propagation hits 95-100%:

DNSMap propagation check

I configure DNSMap after any DNS infrastructure updates. It prevents issues like outages from changes not being visible yet for some visitors.

It’s invaluable insurance for both web developers and network admins after DNS modifications.

Tip: Use DNSMap to validate worldwide DNS propagation whenever you modify DNS records.

This free tool eliminates propagation blind spots after DNS changes.

Specialized Tools – AzureSpeed and CloudPing

For checking cloud provider infrastructure directly, Azure and AWS offer their own specialized tools:

  • AzureSpeed – Tests latency from your location to Azure‘s worldwide data centers. Helps pick lowest latency regions to deploy applications and services.

  • CloudPing – Measures latency to AWS services worldwide. Identifies optimal AWS regions for deploying your workloads.

I use these handy tools as a first pass before deploying resources on Azure or AWS infrastructure. They prevent picking suboptimal locations that seem closer but actually have higher latency.

Tip: Verify your closest low latency Azure and AWS infrastructure using AzureSpeed and CloudPing when planning deployments.

Why guess about cloud provider latency when you can measure it directly?

Key Tool Selection Criteria

With the plethora of DNS and CDN performance tools available, here are key criteria I consider when choosing solutions:

Features: Types of tests offered, depth of metrics, customization flexibility, providers covered.

Usability: Easy setup and testing, intuitive results visualization, automation access.

Scope: Number of global test points, frequency of data collection.

Cost: Free plans available or affordable paid options.

Data Access: Historical data retention, ability to export raw results.

I focus on tools aligned to my specific use cases, whether one-time benchmarking or ongoing monitoring. Leveraging free options can provide immense value.

Paid plans unlock additional features, more extensive testing capabilities, and advanced integrations.

To get complete DNS and CDN visibility, I suggest combining multiple tools:

  • Use DNSPerf for continuous monitoring of core DNS speeds.
  • Leverage Uptrends and CDNPerf Latency Test for recurring website-specific CDN checks.
  • Run CloudHarmony for unbiased CDN and DNS provider comparisons.
  • Use DNS Speed Benchmark and DNSBlast for quick diagnostics.
  • Check DNSMap after any DNS infrastructure changes.

Testing from diverse vantage points using varied techniques provides the most robust data for decision making.

I rely on blended public and internal monitoring to stay ahead of lurking web performance gotchas.

Key Takeaways

  • Optimizing DNS and CDN performance should be a website priority, but is often neglected.
  • Public tools from DNSPerf, CloudHarmony, Uptrends, and CDNPerf provide invaluable speed insights.
  • Mix one-time benchmarking with continuous monitoring for optimal configurations.
  • Consider ease of use, breadth of metrics, flexibility, and cost when selecting tools.
  • Blend multiple tools to get a complete performance perspective.

With the right monitoring and diagnostics, you can confidently identify and resolve DNS and CDN performance gaps limiting your website speed.

I hope these real-world tips help you leverage these tools like a pro to deliver faster experiences for website visitors worldwide!

Written by