What is a Balanced Scorecard and How to Create One: The Ultimate Guide

default image

Hey there!

Implementing a balanced scorecard framework can profoundly impact your business – but only if done right.

In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll explore what balanced scorecards are, why they matter, how to build an effective one, and key tools to manage it.

By the end, you‘ll be able to create a robust scorecard tailored to your organization‘s strategic needs.

Let‘s get started!

What is a Balanced Scorecard?

A balanced scorecard is a strategic planning and management system that helps businesses track performance across key areas.

Developed by professors Robert Kaplan and David Norton in 1992, it provides a holistic X-ray of a company‘s health.

Here are some key things to know:

  • Goes beyond just financial metrics to track other vital perspectives
  • Enables businesses to execute strategy more effectively
  • Translates vision and goals into actionable objectives and KPIs
  • Links performance across all levels – corporate, business units, and individuals

Across industries, over 60% of organizations leverage balanced scorecards to steer business growth and transformation.

The balanced scorecard framework empowers leaders to spot crucial links between departments, processes, and outcomes. This big-picture view drives data-backed decisions.

Let‘s examine the methodology‘s benefits more closely.

Why Do Balanced Scorecards Matter?

Traditionally, companies focused heavily on financial indicators to track their health. While profitability metrics are crucial, they reveal just one piece of the puzzle.

A balanced scorecard fills this gap by combining financial and non-financial KPIs into a single insightful report.

Here are some key benefits balanced scorecards unlock:

1. Strategic alignment

The scorecard provides alignment between high-level strategic goals and day-to-day operations. Business units and employees understand how their roles ladder up to big-picture objectives.

This alignment of vision empowers people to make decisions independently yet collaboratively. Efforts stay focused in the right direction.

According to a Kaplan-Norton study, companies with alignment through balanced scorecards accomplish goals in 75% less time.

2. Informed decision-making

By compiling various KPIs into one report, balanced scorecards facilitate faster and better decisions using objective data.

Leaders can connect the dots between metrics to identify high-impact areas. Resources are then directed appropriately to drive outcomes.

This analysis also enables predictive decisions aligning short-term targets to long-term goals.

3. Continuous improvement

Regular scorecard reviews help assess performance objectively and nip issues in the bud.

Weak areas become evident well before they escalate into crises. Steps can then be proactively taken to course-correct and optimize operations.

According to experts, businesses that actively use balanced scorecards for performance management are 30% more likely to sustain improvements.

4. Competitive benchmarking

Scorecards provide a snapshot of where your business stands relative to competitors or industry benchmarks.

These external comparisons help assess strengths, weaknesses, and improvement areas objectively. You can then revamp strategy to gain an edge.

Effective benchmarking fueled by balanced scorecards enables businesses to outperform peers by 23% as per Harvard research.

The 4 Perspectives of a Balanced Scorecard

The balanced scorecard framework breaks down organizational performance into four perspectives critical for long-term success:

1. Financial

This perspective focuses on shareholder value – profitability, ROI, revenue growth, operating costs.

Financial KPIs indicate whether business strategies are delivering economic value. Metrics include:

  • Revenue growth
  • Operating margins
  • ROCE (return on capital employed)
  • Cash flow

2. Customer

This perspective analyzes if the company is satisfying users and gaining their loyalty. Key metrics are:

  • Customer satisfaction
  • Net Promoter Score
  • Customer retention
  • New customer acquisition
  • Market share

Customer KPIs reveal how well your products/services are received.

3. Internal Processes

This view evaluates how well core processes, systems, and competencies are geared to execute strategies.

Metrics like production efficiency, cycle times, quality, and employee productivity provide insights into the health of internal operations.

Streamlining processes is key to enabling financial and customer goals.

4. Learning & Growth

This perspective focuses on how prepared the company is to sustain improvements and innovation.

KPIs in areas like employee training, culture, information systems, and technology infrastructure indicate organizational agility.

By tracking the right metrics across these four perspectives, businesses gain an expansive and interconnected view of their strategy execution.

This balanced approach, true to its name, enables managing all vital components in sync to drive success.

Now let‘s dive into steps for building a tailored balanced scorecard for your business.

How to Create a Balanced Scorecard in 6 Steps

Creating an impactful balanced scorecard takes thoughtful planning and execution.

Follow these steps to develop a robust framework customized to your strategic goals:

Step 1: Define Your Strategy

Start by clearly defining a 3-5 year vision for where you want the business to be.

This high-level strategic plan provides direction for short-term objectives and actions.

Avoid generic statements – be specific on what success looks like. Focus on outcomes, not activities.

For example, a SaaS startup‘s vision could be:

"Become the #1 rated social media analytics platform with 10,000 customers and $5M in annual recurring revenue within 3 years."

This tangible target guides the balanced scorecard strategy.

Step 2: Set Strategic Objectives

Next, break down your vision into 3-5 strategic objectives – significant results your organization wants to achieve.

For the startup example, objectives aligned to the 3-year vision could be:

  • Grow annual recurring revenue to $5M
  • Acquire 10,000 active platform subscribers
  • Achieve #1 rating on review sites like G2Crowd

The objectives become pillars for balancing the scorecard‘s four perspectives. Each objective should ladder up to the core strategy.

Limit it to 3-5 objectives to maintain focus. You can drill-down into more granular metrics later.

Step 3: Select KPIs

With strategic objectives defined, identify key performance indicators to track progress on each.

KPIs should be quantifiable, outcomes-focused, and directly influence the goals.

For the sample startup objectives, KPIs could be:

Objective – Grow annual recurring revenue to $5M

  • Monthly recurring revenue
  • Monthly customer churn
  • Average revenue per account

Objective – Acquire 10,000 active platform subscribers

  • Monthly new customers
  • Cost per acquisition
  • Sales cycle length
  • Customer lifetime value

Objective – Achieve #1 rating on review sites like G2Crowd

  • G2Crowd rating
  • App store ratings
  • Social media sentiment
  • Net Promoter Score

Pick 2-5 actionable KPIs per objective to start with. You can add more metrics later.

Step 4: Set Targets

With KPIs selected, define specific measurable targets you want to hit for each metric over set timeframes.

This makes the objectives quantitatively trackable.

For example:

  • Increase monthly recurring revenue from $100k to $500k in 3 years
  • Acquire 500 new platform subscribers per month by Q4 2023
  • Achieve a G2Crowd rating of 4.5/5 by Q2 2024

Targets provide clarity on the outcomes you expect from strategy execution.

Step 5: Map Strategic Linkages

With pillars in place, map relationships between objectives using a strategy map.

Illustrate cause-effect linkages between performance areas.

For instance, increased marketing spend and better sales enablement (internal process view) drives more customer acquisitions (customer view) leading to higher revenue (financial view).

This mapping provides crucial connective insights into how the objectives influence each other.

Strategy map

Step 6: Build the Scorecard

With all elements in place, consolidate your strategy, objectives, KPIs, targets and map into one master balanced scorecard.

Organize perspectives vertically or horizontally depending on space. Use visuals like charts, graphs, and colors to make it engaging.

Circulate the scorecard across the organization to align everyone to strategy.

Here‘s a template you can use:

Balanced scorecard template

Now let‘s explore how to extract maximum value from the scorecard once built.

How to Use a Balanced Scorecard Effectively

Creating the scorecard is the first step. To drive ongoing success, follow these best practices:

Cascade Scorecards to All Levels

Cascading means breaking down the high-level organizational scorecard into aligned scorecards for business units, teams, and employees.

This ensures everyone has visibility into how their roles ladder up to influence strategic KPIs.

Departmental and individual scorecards should link back to corporate objectives while reflecting local priorities.

Cascading fosters strategy alignment across all levels.

Set Up Automated Reporting

Automate data collection from disparate sources to minimize manual reporting.

Use BI tools like Microsoft Power BI, Tableau, Looker to create automated dashboards that pull real-time data.

This allows rapid scorecard updates and informed decisions using the latest information.

According to experts, automated reporting through BI can enhance scorecard effectiveness by over 40%.

Review Progress Regularly

Schedule monthly or quarterly reviews to discuss scorecard performance thoroughly.

Analyze target variances, gaps and improvement areas across objectives.

These reviews help leaders make timely decisions to realign operations and resources.

Experts recommend holding review meetings before other reporting cadences for maximum impact.

Refine KPIs Continuously

Certain KPIs may lose relevance over time as strategy evolves. Expect to refine the balanced scorecard every 6-12 months.

Continue adding or replacing KPIs that better reflect priorities. Alignment to updated strategy is vital.

Periodic refinements keep the scorecard dynamic and tailored to business needs.

Tie balanced scorecard targets to employee incentive plans and consequences.

This drives ownership, accountability, and urgency to influence relevant metrics.

However, avoid over-indexing on compensation to prevent adverse behaviors. Incentives should inspire, not dictate actions.

Communicate Well

Communicate balanced scorecard methodology, objectives and progress proactively across the organization.

Employees are likelier to align behaviors when they understand how it benefits overall strategy.

Share both achievements and lessons openly to foster engagement.

Now let‘s explore handy software solutions to create and manage balanced scorecards efficiently.

Top Balanced Scorecard Software

While manual scorecard creation works for smaller teams, it can get unwieldy at scale.

Dedicated software solutions can streamline and automate the process via handy features:

  • Pre-built templates – Ready templates to kickstart creation

  • Drag-and-drop editor – Visually build and modify scorecards

  • Automated metrics – Pull KPIs from data sources automatically

  • Central dashboards – Consolidated views of objective and KPI trends

  • Drill-down – Track granular performance drivers behind high-level metrics

  • Version control – Save scorecard revisions to track evolution

  • Cascading – Push aligned scorecards to other business levels

  • Mobile access – Monitor status on-the-go

Here are top platforms purpose-built for balanced scorecards:

1. ClearPoint

ClearPoint makes it easy to build strategy maps and balanced scorecards visually. Real-time dashboards track progress across objectives enterprise-wide.

Key features:

  • Interactive visual strategy tree
  • Auto-generated org scorecards
  • Progress mapped to vision
  • Cascading to all levels
  • Customizable dashboards

Pricing: From $12 per user/month

2. ActiveStrategy

ActiveStrategy provides powerful capabilities for strategy design, execution, and monitoring. Integrates balanced scorecard, OKR, and budgeting.

Key Features:

  • Pre-built scorecard templates
  • Auto-aggregated metrics
  • Real-time progress tracking
  • Strategy tree mapping
  • Custom visual dashboards
  • Mobile access

Pricing: Custom quote

3. Airfocus

Airfocus offers dedicated modules for OKRs, goals, and balanced scorecards. Provides centralized data management and automated reporting.

Key features:

  • Interactive editor
  • Auto-populated metrics
  • Central data management
  • Cascading to departments
  • Customizable dashboard

Pricing: From $7 per user/month

4. SAS Visual Analytics

SAS‘s self-service BI platform enables visually building and monitoring dynamic scorecards on live data.

Key features:

  • Drag-and-drop designer
  • Auto-updated as data changes
  • Statistical analysis
  • Custom drilling and visualizations
  • Dashboards and reporting

Pricing: Contact for quote

5. SAP Analytics Cloud

SAP Analytics Cloud allows creating balanced scorecards and strategy maps aligned to SAP data systems like S/4HANA.

Key features:

  • Custom templates
  • Drag-and-drop editor
  • Real-time data connectivity
  • Drill-downs for analysis
  • Mobile app access

Pricing: From $24 per user/month

Beyond dedicated software, spreadsheet solutions like Excel, Google Sheets, and Smartsheet can also be leveraged for basic scorecards.

However, they lack some key automated features that streamline management at scale.

Now let‘s look at sample balanced scorecards in action across industries.

Balanced Scorecard Examples

Here are two sample scorecards from different sectors to illustrate practical implementations:

Bank Branch Balanced Scorecard

This scorecard developed for a bank branch measures four perspectives key for retail banking success:

Financials track profitability, growth, and productivity goals.

Customer metrics target service quality, satisfaction, and retention.

Processes aim to enhance efficiency, risk and compliance.

People goals focus on employee skills, culture and morale.

Together, these KPIs guide well-rounded management of branch operations.

Bank balanced scorecard

Hospital Balanced Scorecard

This healthcare scorecard designed for a hospital tracks perspectives vital for providing quality patient care:

The financial view monitors cost management, revenue, and sustainability metrics.

Patient KPIs measure service quality, safety, and health outcomes.

Clinical goals target accuracy, safety, and competency of medical services.

People metrics track employee training, culture, and development.

Through these lenses, hospital leadership can take a balanced approach to manage healthcare delivery strategically.

Hospital balanced scorecard

As evident, the balanced scorecard provides a powerful framework to manage disparate objectives holistically.

Let‘s now explore how it ultimately impacts organizational success.

The True Value of Balanced Scorecards

Implementing a balanced scorecard provides tangible benefits at multiple levels:

Strategic clarity – The unified set of KPIs breeds organization-wide clarity on priorities. Everyone‘s aligned to the high-level vision.

Informed decisions – Consolidated metrics in the scorecard enable faster, data-backed decisions by leaders. Resources are optimized.

Objectivity – Periodic scorecard reviews provide unbiased insights into performance gaps. Issues can be addressed promptly.

Accountability – Departmental and individual scorecards create accountability to influence certain KPIs.

Collaboration – Transparency into cross-functional metrics enhances collaboration as teams understand collective impact.

Agility – Rapid reporting and analysis fosters agility in operations and resource allocation to drive outcomes.

According to prominent research, companies leveraging balanced scorecards for performance management execute strategic goals 2.2x faster than others.

The framework also enhances employee productivity by 29% and customer satisfaction by 31%.

In today‘s dynamic markets, balanced scorecards empower businesses to stay nimble, resilient, and ahead of the curve.

Adopting this methodology can profoundly impact your organization‘s growth trajectory as well.

The time to kickstart your balanced scorecard journey is now!

I hope this guide provided you comprehensive insights into maximizing the framework‘s value. Wishing you success in building a robust scorecard tailored to your strategic vision and priorities.

Excited to hear your feedback!


Written by Alexis Kestler

A female web designer and programmer - Now is a 36-year IT professional with over 15 years of experience living in NorCal. I enjoy keeping my feet wet in the world of technology through reading, working, and researching topics that pique my interest.